PROVINCIAL ASSEMBLY OF SINDH
ORDERS OF THE DAY
WEDNESDAY, THE 12TH JUNE, 2024
Business to be brought forward before the Legislature on Wednesday, the 12th June, 2024 at 11.00A.M.
I. (A) RECITATION FROM THE HOLY QUR’AN.
(B) NAAT SHAREEF.
II. OATH BY THE MEMBERS-ELECT WHO HAVE NOT YET MADE OATH AND SIGNING OF ROLL OF MEMBERS, IF ANY.
III. QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS:
(School Education and Literacy Department)
IV. CALL ATTENTION NOTICES:
01. CALL ATTENTION NOTICE NO. 06 OF 2024;GIVEN NOTICE OF BY MR. NASEER AHMED, MPA: Will the Honourable Minister for Local Government, Sindh may please to give answer/ statement on the dire state of public transportation in Karachi, particularly the Red Bus Route which is not in Manghopir Town, which falls under my Constituency PS-118. The residents of Manghopir Town and surrounding areas are facing immense difficulties due to the inadequate and unreliable public transport system?
02. CALL ATTENTION NOTICE NO. 08 OF 2024;GIVEN NOTICE OF BY MR. REHAN AKRAM, MPA: Will the Honourable Minister for Local Government, Sindh may please to give answer/ statement that residents of my Constituency Sector-4 and 11-B are much worried due to shortage of water; What measures are being taken by the Government to meet the shortage of water?
03. CALL ATTENTION NOTICE NO. 07 OF 2024;GIVEN NOTICE OF BY MR. WAJID HUSSAIN KHAN, MPA: Will the Honourable Minister for Local Government, Sindh may please to give answer/ statement that there is shortage of drinking water in my Constituency PS-92 Landhi main reason of the shortage is Tanker Mafia, supply of water through illegal hydrants to the Tanker Mafia should be stopped to provide the facility of drinking water to the people of my Constituency?
V. LEAVE APPLICATION OF MEMBERS, IF ANY.
VI. PRIVILEGE MOTION, IF ANY.
VII. ADJOURNMENT MOTION NO. 06 OF 2024;GIVEN NOTICE OF BY MS. TANZILA UMI HABIBA, MPA REGARDING NEED FOR ALLOCATION OF ADDITIONAL FUNDS FOR MISSING FACILITIES FOR EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS.
VIII. INTRODUCTION AND CONSIDERATION OF THE GOVERNMENT BILL NO. 04 OF 2024-THE GORAKH HILLS DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY (AMENDMENT) BILL, 2024.
IX. DISCUSSION ON ADJOURNMENT MOTION NO. 01 OF 2024;GIVEN NOTICE OF BY MS. HEER SOHO, MPA REGARDING INCREASING GAS LOAD-SHEDDING IN THE PROVINCE.
X. ANY OTHER BUSINESS WITH THE PERMISSION OF THE CHAIR.
KARACHI, THE G.M.UMAR FAROOQ
11TH JUNE, 2024 SECRETARY
PROVINCIAL ASSEMBLY OF SINDH
PROVINCIAL ASSEMBLY OF SINDH
SCHOOL EDUCATION AND LITERACY DEPARTMENT
LIST OF STARRED ASSEMBLY QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS FOR
WEDNESDAY, THE 12TH JUNE, 2024
05 *Mr. Ali Khurshidi:
Will the Minister for Education be pleased to State:-
Number of incidents happened in which students become unconscious due to drinking of poisonous water/food in various schools of the Province during 01-01-2020 to 01-01-2023 including precautionary measures taken to prevent such incidents in future?
ANSWER
SYED SARDAR ALI SHAH: MINISTER FOR EDUCATION:-
It is stated that there is no case reported where students become unconscious due to drinking poisonous water/food in various Schools of the Province during 01-01-2020 to 01-01-2023.
06 *Mr. Ali Khurshidi:
Will the Minister for Education be pleased to State:-
(a) Whether the teachers were dismissed from service being absent from duty during 2018 to 2023;
(b) If answer to (a) above is affirmative, the details thereof alongwith policy for the same?
ANSWER
SYED SARDAR ALI SHAH: MINISTER FOR EDUCATION:-
The Director of Monitoring & Evaluation identified 7159 Absconder during the academic year 2018 to 2023 as per M&E policy 2017 which was reported to concerned authority i.e., Directors / DEOs for the disciplinary proceeding.
However, this office has been informed by the Director / DEOs that the disciplinary proceedings against approximately 2500 teaching and non –teaching staff was concluded, out of which 1260 employees have been awarded major penalty of “Removal from Service”. The region-wise detail is as under:-
|
S.NO
|
Division
|
No of staff awarded major Penalties of “Removal from Service” |
|
1 |
Hyderabad |
207 |
|
2 |
Karachi |
467 |
|
3 |
Larkana |
310 |
|
4 |
Mirpurkhas |
65 |
|
5 |
SBA |
155 |
|
6 |
Sukkur |
56 |
|
Grand Total |
1260 |
|
33 *Mr. Ali Khurshidi:
Will the Minister for Education be pleased to State:-
District-wise number of Government girls primary schools, where no washroom facility is available in Karachi Division along with intention of the government to provide the same?
ANSWER
SYED SARDAR ALI SHAH: MINISTER FOR EDUCATION:-
There are 330 girls’ primary schools in Karachi Division. Out of these, 292 primary schools have washroom facilities, in which 38 schools do not have washroom facilities. District-wise details of girl’s primary schools and with or without washrooms are at Annexure placed on the Table of the House.
53 *Ms. Qurat-ul-Ain Khan:
Will the Minister for Education be pleased to State:-
District-wise number/name of Government Schools adopted by NGO’s in Sindh Province alongwith the name of NGO’s during 2019 to 2023?
ANSWER
SYED SARDAR ALI SHAH: MINISTER FOR EDUCATION:-
The following Schools of various levels have been adopted by different NGO’s/Individuals from 2019 to 2023 as per under mentioned matrix;
|
Year |
No. of Schools |
|
2019 |
25 |
|
2020 |
21 |
|
2021 |
33 |
|
2022 |
02 |
|
2023 |
64 |
|
Total |
145 |
115 *Ms. Qurat-ul-Ain Khan:
Will the Minister for Education be pleased to State:-
District-wise number of Government Schools in Sindh where Science and I-T Lab facilities are available?
ANSWER
SYED SARDAR ALI SHAH: MINISTER FOR EDUCATION:-
(a) There are 40,978 Government Schools working under SELD, Sindh.
(b) Out of these 740 schools have Computer Labs facilities, while 1,216 schools have Science Labs.
It is relevant to mentioned here mostly Computer labs are in secondary and higher secondary schools, due to optional subject of computer science in secondary classes.
While in non-secondary schools there are some computer labs reported in primary, middle and elementary schools which were established through some special initiatives / projects funded either by SELD or any other donor.
The reflection of huge gap between number of schools and computer labs is due to non-essential requirement of these labs in primary, middle and elementary schools.
(c) The details of the distribution of Computer / Science labs as per School level are as under:-
|
School Level |
Numbers of Schools |
|||
|
Total |
Boys |
Girls |
Mixed |
|
|
Primary |
36,225 |
14,190 |
4,500 |
17,535 |
|
Middle |
1,581 |
498 |
431 |
652 |
|
Elementary |
1,027 |
283 |
267 |
477 |
|
Secondary |
1,654 |
585 |
497 |
572 |
|
Higher Secondary |
491 |
186 |
121 |
184 |
|
Grand Total |
40,978 |
15,742 |
5,816 |
19,420 |
124 *Ms. Bilqees Mukhtar:
Will the Minister for Education be pleased to State:-
How many times test conducted for the appointment of teachers through IBA Sukkur last years in Sindh as well as number of aspirants qualified the exam and the qualification/criteria of those qualified?
ANSWER
SYED SARDAR ALI SHAH: MINISTER FOR EDUCATION:-
|
From 2001 onwards teachers of various cadres have been appointed through third party testing service as per following matrix;
|
||||
|
Third party Testing Agency |
Year |
|||
|
Sindh Public Service Commission |
2001 |
|||
|
College of Business Management (CBM) |
2004 |
|||
|
Iqra University |
2006 |
|||
|
Sukkur IBA |
2008,2018,2021-22 |
|||
|
Sindh University |
2009 |
|||
|
NTS |
2013 |
|||
|
The Details of, passed and appointed candidate through IBA Sukkur
|
||||
|
Year |
Pass Candidate |
Appointed Candidates |
||
|
2017-18 |
JEST |
6578 |
2887 |
|
|
ECT |
1589 |
716 |
||
|
2021-22 |
JEST |
61230 |
18470 |
|
|
PST |
86436 |
45426 |
||
|
2023 Deprived |
JEST |
3806 |
1140 |
|
|
PST |
4601 |
1050 |
||
125 *Ms. Bilqees Mukhtar:
Will the Minister for Education be pleased to State:-
Location-wise number/names of Government Schools which are running under the administration of private institutions in the province?
ANSWER
SYED SARDAR ALI SHAH: MINISTER FOR EDUCATION:-
|
Sr# |
EMOs |
No. of Schools and Groups of School |
|
1 |
Charter of Compassion |
30 |
|
2 |
Sukkur IBA |
29 |
|
3 |
BPS (PVT) Ltd |
05 |
|
4 |
Indus Resource Center |
01 |
|
5 |
Sindh Rural Support Organization |
13 |
|
6 |
HANDS |
60 |
|
7 |
The Citizen Foundation |
19 |
|
8 |
Dare Arqam |
08 |
|
9 |
MD Zed (SZABIT) |
10 |
|
10 |
Sindh Madresah Board |
20 |
|
11 |
Research and Development Foundation |
16 |
|
Total |
211 |
|
135 *Ms. Bilqees Mukhtar:
Will the Minister for Education be pleased to State:-
Is it fact that drop of female children in the schools of Sindh has been increased upto 54% which is an alarming situation if so, steps taken by Education Department of Sindh in this regard?
ANSWER
SYED SARDAR ALI SHAH: MINISTER FOR EDUCATION:-
Major Response
"No! Not at all. As per reported statistics of 2022-23, the total enrollment of the students in government schools was reported as 4,689,348 (2,791,595 boys + 1,897,753 girls) has now been increased to 5,236,202 (3,080,923 boys +2,155,279 girls) that shows an overall increase of 13% in enrollment. The same statistics further reveal that there is 13.3% increase in the girls enrolment this year".
Elaboration- Steps are being taken
Several initiatives are in progress to bring a school a child into schools with quality education e.g. Construction, Up gradation, Renovation of building, Academic Facilities, TLM Staffing, CPD, M&E, Enrollment drives and projects i.e. SELECT, ASPIRE, SID, STEAM, DEEP, JICA, SBEP, EMS-CHS, SSEIP etc. However, Covid-19, Floods, Taboos, poverty and flawed set up (88% to 4% primary to secondary) are the reason for dropout and OOSC.
In such a challenging scenario not only the dropouts and inaccessibility but unchecked migration causes high OOSC in Sindh. Keeping all possible solution in view, the people's government also preferred Non Formal Education -Accelerated Learning Program, as one of the alternative strategies to address the educational challenges of the province.
205 *Mr. Abdul Basit:
Will the Minister for Education be pleased to State:-
(a) Is it a fact that there have been issues regarding the attendance app for government school teachers in Sindh?
(b) If the answer to (a) above is affirmative, what steps have been taken to resolve the issue of the attendance app for government school teachers in Sindh?
ANSWER
SYED SARDAR ALI SHAH: MINISTER FOR EDUCATION:-
a) PMS (Project Management System) application is an online application implemented for Teachers Daily Attendance under the directives of High Court of Sindh, CP-1937/2020.
b) Piloting the system across 12 districts (Karachi South, Hyderabad, Jamshoro, Matiari, TandoAllahyar, Tando Muhammad Khan, Dadu, QambarShadadkot, KashmoreKandhkot, Sukkur, Mirpurkhas, Umerkot) is a substantial undertaking and suggests a commitment to thorough validation and optimization before rolling out in all over Sindh.
c) Application being developed by NITB (National Information Technology Board) with hosting services provided by NTC (National Telecommunication Corporation).
d) There are many issues persist in the PMS application like login, punch in/out, leave applications, and report generation. This office addressed the said issues in written to NITB multiple times, yet have not been resolved nor any response received from NITB.
Hence, the Department has decided in the meeting held on 22-04-2024 to develop a new application of same nature which will work offline for teachers to mark their attendance.
209 *Mr. Abdul Basit:
Will the Minister for Education be pleased to State:-
Details on which district in Sindh has the lowest and highest students enrollment in Government schools?
ANSWER
SYED SARDAR ALI SHAH: MINISTER FOR EDUCATION:-
As per the enrollment of Government Schools provided by field team of Directorate General of M&E, the highest enrollment district of Sindh is Khairpur Mir's, the total enrollment of Khairpuir Mir's district is 413,579, whereas lowest enrollment district of Sindh is Kahmore at Kandhkot, the total enrollment of Kashmore at Kandhkot district is 40,458.
The district-wise enrollment of Government Schools are as under: -
|
Sr.# |
District |
Enrollment |
Sr.# |
District |
Enrollment |
Sr. # |
District |
Enrollment |
|
1 |
KhairpurMirs |
413,579 |
11 |
Tharparkar@ Mithi |
209,874 |
21 |
Karachi West |
88,695 |
|
2 |
Umerkot |
325,469 |
12 |
Karachi Malir |
207,910 |
22 |
Karachi East |
88,213 |
|
3 |
Larkana |
324,601 |
13 |
Sukkur |
205,290 |
23 |
Jamshoro |
86,488 |
|
4 |
Dadu |
296,523 |
14 |
Shaikharpur |
183,394 |
24 |
T.M Khan |
84,140 |
|
5 |
Jacobabad |
285,878 |
15 |
Ghotki |
176,803 |
25 |
Karachi Central |
79,607 |
|
6 |
Karachi South |
277,544 |
16 |
Badin |
171,605 |
26 |
Karachi Korangi |
74,556 |
|
7 |
Sujawal |
254,134 |
17 |
Shaheed Benazirabad |
166,581 |
27 |
Hyderabad |
52,244 |
|
8 |
TandoAllahar |
254,005 |
18 |
Mirpurkhas |
124,675 |
28 |
KambarShahdadkot |
51,875 |
|
9 |
Thatta |
226,937 |
19 |
Naushaheroferoze |
112,111 |
29 |
Matiari |
44,304 |
|
10 |
Karachi Kemari |
221,569 |
20 |
Sanghar |
107,189 |
30 |
Kashmore@ Kandhkot |
40,458 |